Eagle Pass Housing Authority Board majority terminates Executive Director Carla Mancha-Juarez
By: Jose G. Landa
Copyright 2013
A majority of the Housing Authority of the City of Eagle Pass, Texas Board of Commissioners voted to terminate its Executive Director Carla Y. Mancha-Juarez by a four to one vote at its regular Board meeting on Thursday, August 22, 2013, in Eagle Pass.
Eagle Pass Housing Authority Vice-Chairperson Jose Gonzalez made a motion to terminate Carla Y. Mancha-Juarez for cause effective immediately as Executive Director reading from a prepared written script and Commissioner Delfina Garza Morales seconded the motion. Commissioners Jose Gonzalez, Delfina Garza Morales, Pete Venegas, and Chairperson Ana Gonzalez voted in favor of the motion to terminate Mancha-Juarez.
Commissioner Ricardo E. Calderon voted against the motion to terminate citing there was not sufficient legal cause to terminate Mancha-Juarez and warned his fellow Commissioners that their action might cause the local governmental entity tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars for a wrongful termination lawsuit.
EPHA Vice-Chairperson Jose Gonzalez stated his reasons for making the motion to terminate Mancha-Juarez immediately for cause included that since he has served on the Eagle Pass Housing Authority Board of Commissioners for 17 months there are too many problems going on, personnel discontent, two doubtful financial matters which he did not specify, and so the problems seem to be piling up causing him to lose his vote of confidence in Administration (Mancha-Juarez). Gonzalez added that he could expound more on his reasons, but that he wanted to keep his comments short.
Commissioner Delfina Garza Morales stated her reasons for seconding the motion to terminate Mancha-Juarez immediately for cause was because she does not have confidence in Mancha-Juarez’s work as Executive Director of the Eagle Pass Housing Authority. Commissioner Garza chose not to elaborate or specifically state what were the causes for her seconding the motion to terminate with cause other than the lack of confidence. Mancha-Juarez stood up and requested that Commissioner Garza specify her reasons for cause. Chairperson Ana Gonzalez immediately intervened and told Mancha-Garza that this is all Commissioner Garza had to say. Commissioner Calderon replied that since the motion was for termination with cause, the Commissioners needed to specify their reasons for termination for cause.
Chairperson Gonzalez asked EPHA’s General Counsel Heriberto Morales of Langley & Banack if the Commissioners needed to specify their reasons. Morales replied that their legal position is that the Commissioners do not have to elaborate, but their advice to Commissioners is that if the motion to terminate is made with cause then the Commissioners have to specify their reasons, and that if the motion to terminate is made without cause then the Commissioners do not have to specify their reasons.
Commissioner Pete Venegas stated that in the short period that he has been on the EPHA’s Board, all he has heard are complaints from former employees, present employees, and his fellow Board of Commissioners. Commissioner Venegas stated that therefore he did not feel comfortable with the direction that this present Administrator (Mancha-Juarez) is providing the Housing Authority. Later in the meeting, Commissioner Calderon asked Commissioner Venegas if he (Calderon) has ever spoken to him outside the Board meetings and board room regarding EPHA business to which Venegas replied “No.” Calderon asked Venegas which Commissioners had he spoken to that had complained to him to which Venegas replied Commissioner Delfina Garza Morales. Chairperson Gonzalez and General Counsel Heriberto Morales intervened and cut off Commissioner Calderon from asking Commissioners any further questions during the public hearing.
Chairperson Ana Gonzalez stated that her personal reasons for supporting the motion to terminate with cause included that at the July 16, 2013 Board of Commissioners meeting the Executive Director (Mancha-Juarez) allowed two top Department Heads to speak to the Board during the Citizens Communications without adhering to personnel policies, the constant overturn of personnel including the hiring of what will be the fourth Financial Officer during the past two years, the Executive Director (Mancha-Juarez) violated the By-laws of the EPHA by not notifying in writing the Board of Commissioners of all vacancies and job openings prior to the selection or firing of said positions, the quality inspections are not being done timely causing vacancies delayed, that the Audit by the U.S. Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Department’s Office of Inspector General was not presented first to the Board, the Executive Director (Mancha-Juarez) had the Chairperson countersign over 450 checks per month, the Executive Director (Mancha-Juarez) alllowed EPHA Employees to sign a petition to the Board of Commissioners in support of the Executive Director during work hours and got employees involved in her personnel issue before the Board, was not strict with all of the employees and did not treat all personnel the same, misled the Board of Commissioners on Section 8 financial problems, and the recapture of $680,363 by HUD of EPHA low rent monies because of surplus funds in the budget.
Commissioner Calderon was the lone Board member voting against the motion to terminate for cause stating there was a lack of evidence for termination for cause, the EPHA has earned seven consecutive HUD High Performer Awards with an eighth award forthcoming in Section 8 public housing being the highest possible HUD award for outstanding performance under the leadership of Executive Director Carla Y. Mancha-Juarez, the EPHA has earned three consecutive HUD High Performer Awards in Low Rent Public Housing being the highest possible HUD award for outstanding performance under the leadership of Executive Director Carla Y. Mancha-Juarez, the EPHA received HUD’s Office of Inspector General commendation for its 2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act Grant activities with one minor exception under the leadership of Mancha-Juarez, the development of a budget surplus over $2,500,000 and the approval of a balanced budget for fiscal year 2013-2014 under the leadership of Mancha-Juarez despite sequestration cuts by Congress, the positive evaluation of Mancha-Juarez by the same board except Commissioner Venegas who was not on the board during March 2013, the greatly improved operations of the EPHA under Mancha-Juarez compared to past Administrations according to HUD, the professional management of personnel, the existence of an employment contract for the services of Mancha-Juarez as Executive Director, the possibility of expensive litigation expenses and potential damages in the tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars, the petition of support for Mancha-Juarez of over 21 EPHA employees to the Board of Commissioners, and other reasons.
Earlier in the meeting during the Citizens Communication of the agenda, EPHA Executive Director Carla Y. Mancha-Juarez spoke to the Board of Commissioners stating that for “nine years I have administered the Eagle Pass Housing Authority with total and complete financial transparency. And the EPHA under my administration has never received a black eye for mismanagement of funds or fraud which was something that was an everyday occurrence under several previous administrations. In fact, last week a report was published in the OIG HUD national based website commending us for our stellar performance in applying the ARRA Stimulus Funds. That was an item that I had on the agenda for this meeting but it was taken out by Madam Chair Gonzalez. I can only conclude that anything positive that I and my staff have contributed does not fit with the agenda at hand.”
Mancha-Juarez added that “I was evaluated in March of this year and here I am being evaluated once more and for consideration of termination. What has happened between March 2013 to today is that we have one new Board member and there had been indefinite micromanagement involvement by Madam Chair, which began last year which has had an effect on the morale of our employees. I done nothing wrong by exercising my administrative judgment instead of following management instructions given to me that directly affect employees; that is a function is the exclusive responsibility of the executive director. I have used my administrative discretion which have overridden one Board Member’s directive as follow: to withhold any type of increase to a certain department head who has worked for eighteen years regardless of her job performance; to apply enough pressure on a maintenance Mechanic A who has been here for almost fifteen years to cause him to quit, or to even fire him without regard to the employee’s job performance; to address Commissioner Garza so that the charges she filed with the Eagle Pass Police Department be taken out–tampering with government records;and recommending to engage in negotiations to bring down the value of a bid, even though I have been advised that is not legal. The list goes on and on, but this is enough to provide, on the record, the thrust of my concerns.”





